Originally posted at LiveJournal on Mar. 22, 2012 EDIT 04-24-12: EOTW Challenge progress: 2515 pages 2464 pages . I discussed it with the Booksluts , and they said I can use Whalesinger as long as I don't count the first 51 pages. Also, I'm including the Afterword to Isabel of the Whales . See my reviews of Whalesinger (212 pages) and Isabel of the Whales (181 pages*) at Postcards . * That's if you count the author's Afterword to Isabel of the Whales . If the challenge-makers say nay, then the story itself is 173 pages, and my total page count is 2507. Also, I had started Whalesinger years ago, but put it down after the first four chapters (51 pages). Depending on what the challenge-makers say, I may have to not count the book, or at least start...